Overview
On May 14, 2026, the Supreme Court of the United States issued its unanimous decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, overturning a decision by the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. The Seventh Circuit held the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (“FAAAA”) preempted all state laws relating to the prices, routes, and services of the trucking industry as to any party, thus preventing parties injured in trucking automobile accidents from suing third-party transportation brokers who coordinated the shipment.1
The Supreme Court granted certiorari and overturned the Seventh Circuit’s decision. The Supreme Court held that while the FAAAA does exempt transportation brokers from state tort lawsuits resulting from intrastate routes they coordinate, the Act provides a safety exception that only applies to interstate routes. Essentially, the Court ruled that the language of the FAAAA allows for third-party transportation brokers to be sued under state tort laws when the truck and shipment they coordinated got into an accident while on a route going from state-to-state.
Historical Background
The Supreme Court of the United States described in detail the FAAAA, its historical significance, and the prevailing sentiments which led to its creation. The Court begins by explaining that sellers of goods often use motor carriers to transport products, but because finding a carrier can be burdensome, many sellers rely on third-party brokerage companies to do it for them. This practice has become so beneficial that, “Today, roughly 28,000 brokers arrange transportation for about a third of all freight shipped in the United States by more than 780,000 carriers. . . Brokers net the difference between the price that a company will pay to move goods and the cost of hiring a carrier.”2
After the Federal Government began regulating the trucking industry in 1935, state regulation continued to inhibit competition. To solve this issue, Congress passed the FAAAA in 1994, which preempted certain state regulations of motor carriers. In 1995, Congress amended the Act to provide protection for other parties in the industry, including third-party freight brokers. Within the Act is a “safety exemption,” designed so that the states would still retain the authority to enact motor vehicle regulations regarding safety.
SCOTUS Opinion and Key Holdings
The plaintiff, Shawn Montgomery, sustained severe injuries after his tractor trailer was struck by a truck carrying a load of plastic through Illinois for Caribe Transport II, LLC. Montgomery filed state tort law claims in federal court against various defendants including C.H. Robinson Worldwide, Inc., a third-party transportation broker who coordinated the shipment. Montogomery brought state court negligent hiring claims against C.H. Robinson, alleging that it knew or should have known from Caribe Transport’s safety rating that hiring it to transport goods was reasonably likely to result in a crash which would injure others.
Both the federal district court and the Seventh Circuit dismissed Montgomery’s claims against C.H. Robinson, relying on prior case law holding the FAAAA prevented plaintiffs from bringing such lawsuit against third-party brokers, and Montgomery’s claims did not fall within the Act’s “safety exemption” which otherwise allows states to pass legislation regulating the trucking industry provided that said regulations are pertaining to the safety of motor vehicles. The relevant portions of the FAAAA (49 U.S. Code §14501) are as follows:
(b)Freight Forwarders and Brokers.—
(1)General rule.—
. . . no State or political subdivision thereof and no intrastate agency or other political agency of 2 or more States shall enact or enforce any law, rule, regulation, standard, or other provision having the force and effect of law relating to intrastate rates, intrastate routes, or intrastate services of any freight forwarder or broker.
. . .
(c)Motor Carriers of Property.—
(1)General rule.—
Except as provided in paragraphs (2) and (3), a State, political subdivision of a State, or political authority of 2 or more States may not enact or enforce a law, regulation, or other provision having the force and effect of law related to a price, route, or service of any motor carrier . . . or any motor private carrier, broker, or freight forwarder with respect to the transportation of property.
(2)Matters not covered.—Paragraph (1)—
(A)shall not restrict the safety regulatory authority of a State with respect to motor vehicles, the authority of a State to impose highway route controls or limitations based on the size or weight of the motor vehicle or the hazardous nature of the cargo, or the authority of a State to regulate motor carriers with regard to minimum amounts of financial responsibility relating to insurance requirements and self-insurance authorization;
Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett wrote the majority opinion, finding that the phrase “with respect to motor vehicles” within the safety exemption of §14501(c)(2)(A) allows states to regulate, and permits claimants to file lawsuits pursuant to said regulations, concerning motor vehicle safety. This includes claims of negligent hiring against third-party transportation brokers, as requiring brokers to exercise ordinary care in selecting carriers “concerns” motor vehicles. Because motor carriers could get into accidents and injure others, claims of negligent hiring thus fall within a state’s authority to regulate for safety.
As to the differentiation between claims involving intrastate routes as opposed to interstate routes, the Court held that because §14501(b) solely pertains to third-party brokers, intrastate commerce, and does not contain a safety exemption, states cannot regulate and plaintiffs cannot bring negligent hiring claims against freight brokers when the route begins and ends within a single state. While Justice Barrett notes it is unclear why Congress did not include a safety exemption for the brokerage of intrastate routes, the act as it stands only provides the ability to bring state claims when the route spans more than one state. In a concurrence written by Justice Brett Kavanaugh, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, Justice Kavanaugh writes, “Second, all agree that the Act as amended does not permit state tort suits against brokers for arranging intrastate transportation.”3 (sic).
Impact and Analysis
Now, what does this mean for the legal landscape, third-party brokers, and the freight transportation industry as a whole?
Justic Kavanaugh highlights valid concerns which third-party brokers hold, being that state tort law can be unpredictable, the costs of litigation and insurance will be significant even when brokers prevail in lawsuits, and these increased costs will likely “cascade” through the industry and be paid in part by American consumers.4 Whether this happens and how the industry will react remains to be seen.
In addition to increased costs, freight brokers will need to institute policies regarding the selection of carriers, monitoring and storing of communications, and comprehensive documentation of selecting carriers, all created with an eye towards defending against lawsuits. These aspects of the brokers’ operations will be discoverable and unearthed during litigation – as freight brokers will undoubtedly be named as defendants every time there is an accident involving a motor carrier. These policies and practices are crucial to successfully defend against said claims, as the brokers will need to show they took steps to fulfill their duty of reasonable care. It may also be beneficial for the affected parties to include specialized defense and indemnity language within the freight contracts if not done so already.
For the legal community, this creates a necessity to foster relationships and educate the affected parties as to their rights, responsibilities, and what must be done to protect themselves. Now there is an entire class of entities and individuals who will be subjected to threats of liability for what may often be spurious claims. It also provides an opportunity to engage with a facet of the freight transportation industry which previously had no need for casualty litigation counsel, and likely never had to consider risks of tort liability when contracting with motor carriers.
Conclusion
In total, the Supreme Court’s decision may be one of the most impactful judicial opinions in recent memory. It may aid in ensuring the nation’s roadways become safer by excluding dangerous drivers from the transportation industry, while at the same time increasing costs across the board for all kinds of products. This opinion creates a need for expert legal counsel in both contract drafting, creating internal policies, and in defending against state law negligent hiring claims which could potentially result in jury verdicts valued in millions of dollars.
Furthermore, this opinion exhibits the tendency of the current Supreme Court in ruling on cases via an originalist and textualist philosophy, which refrains from rewriting laws because Congress left certain questions unanswered. It will be interesting to see whether Congress clarifies the FAAAA by adding a safety exemption to §14501(b) or instead provides third-party freight brokers with comprehensive liability shield against all state law claims.
____________________
1 Montgomery v. Caribe Transp. II LLC, 2026 U.S. LEXIS 2036, at *1 (May 14, 2026).
2 Id. at *5.
3 Id. at *15.
4 Id. at *20.